DivAgent
LeaderboardPortfoliosPortfolio App
Log InGet Started
DivAgent

The institutional-grade income auditor for the retail investor. Stop chasing yield. Start building wealth.

Academy

  • The Income Illusion
  • Defensive Income
  • Avoid Yield Traps
  • View All Courses

Tools & Resources

  • Risk Spectrum Calculator
  • NAV Erosion Check
  • Dividend Glossary
  • Strategy Articles
  • Article Categories
  • Ticker Database Index
  • Comparison Directory

Portfolio App

  • Track Dividends
  • Import Holdings
  • View Dashboard
Free Tier Available

Company

  • Manifesto
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Join 10,000+ Dividend Investors

Weekly insights on sustainable income strategies. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Important Legal Disclaimer

DivAgent is not a registered investment advisor, broker-dealer, or financial analyst. The content on divagent.ai and app.divagent.ai, including ticker audits, risk tiers, dividend forecasts, and "Monthly Expense Kill Lists," is provided for informational and educational purposes only.

Nothing on this platform constitutes a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. Investing involves substantial risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance, including dividend history, is no guarantee of future results.

Data Accuracy & AI Usage: Dividend data is sourced from third-party providers (including Yahoo Finance). Additionally, portions of the content on this site, including articles, summaries, and analysis, may be generated by Artificial Intelligence (AI). While we strive for accuracy, DivAgent does not guarantee the timeliness, completeness, or correctness of any data or AI-generated content. Predictive forecasts are based on mathematical heuristics and should not be relied upon for financial planning.

Limitation of Liability: DivAgent shall not be held liable for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the content, whether human-written or AI-generated, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon.

By using this site, you acknowledge that you are solely responsible for your own investment decisions. Consult with a qualified financial professional before making any financial commitments.

© 2026 DivAgent. All rights reserved.

DivAgent is an informational platform, not a registered investment advisor. Nothing here is financial advice.

LIVEComparison Engine
Last Updated: April 4, 2026

IWMYvsJEPY

Two of the market's most popular income ETFs compared side-by-side. See which one fits your yield strategy.

Data Live

What This Page Shows

  • Yield leader: IWMY (12.48% spread)
  • Safer risk tier: IWMY
  • 1Y total return spread: 7.47%
  • Fees, NAV stability, and payout quality side-by-side
  1. Home
  2. Directory
  3. I
  4. IWMY vs JEPY

At a Glance

HEAD-TO-HEAD
IWMY
Defiance
VS
JEPY
Defiance
33.76%
Annual Yield
21.28%
Tier 4
Risk Tier
Tier 4
7.47%
1Y Total Return
—
-26.29%
1Y NAV Stability
—
1.05%
Expense Ratio
1.01%
-34.33%
Max Drawdown (1Y)
-21.41%
Quick Verdict: JEPY wins on2key metrics.

DivAgent Risk Spectrum

Proprietary Model
Tier 1: Cornerstone
Tier 2: Yield Plus
Tier 3: Specialty
Tier 4: Harvest
Tier 5: Octane
IWMY
JEPY
Tier 1: Cornerstone
Tier 2: Yield Plus
Tier 3: Specialty
Tier 4: Harvest
Tier 5: Octane

What this means: Both IWMY and JEPY fall intoTier 4: Harvest. This suggests they share a similar risk profile and volatility expectation.

Deep Dive Analysis

MetricIWMYJEPY
Total Return (1Y)7.47%0.00%
NAV Change (1Y)-26.29%0.00%
Max Drawdown-34.33%-21.41%
Beta--

* Returns include dividend reinvestment. Drawdown calculates peak-to-trough decline over trailing 12 months.

The DivAgent Analyst Take

IWMY and JEPY are siblings from the same Defiance fund family, using the same aggressive enhanced-options playbook on two very different indices. IWMY harvests volatility from the Russell 2000; JEPY does the same on the S&P 500. The result: a 10-percentage-point yield gap (32.14% vs 21.28%) that tells you exactly how much more volatile small caps are compared to large caps.

Key Differences Between IWMY and JEPY

Underlying Index Risk

The Russell 2000 is inherently more volatile than the S&P 500 — smaller companies, less analyst coverage, more sensitivity to credit conditions. IWMY captures that volatility as options premium. In good times, that's a yield windfall. In downturns, small caps fall harder and faster, meaning IWMY's NAV erodes more aggressively than JEPY's. The 32% yield isn't magic; it's the market pricing in that risk.

Sustainability of Distributions

Both ETFs use enhanced options strategies — likely 0DTE or very short-dated contracts — that generate exceptional near-term income but consume NAV over time. JEPY's 21.28% yield on the S&P 500 is more stable because S&P 500 options markets are deeper and more consistently liquid. IWMY's 32.14% is likely to vary more quarter to quarter as Russell 2000 volatility fluctuates. Neither distribution is guaranteed.

Price Trajectory and Total Return

IWMY trades at $19.09; JEPY at $44.01. The price difference alone is irrelevant — what matters is NAV trend over time. Both ETFs should be evaluated on total return (distributions minus NAV erosion), not yield in isolation. Investors who reinvest distributions may offset decay, but those taking income in cash must monitor NAV carefully to avoid consuming principal.

Which Should You Buy?

Choose IWMY if:

  • You want maximum yield and accept small-cap volatility
  • You're allocating a small satellite position, not core income
  • You believe small caps are entering a bull cycle
  • You actively monitor NAV and will exit if erosion accelerates

Choose JEPY if:

  • You want high income with S&P 500 as the underlying
  • You prefer more predictable options liquidity and pricing
  • You're comfortable with 21% yield rather than chasing 32%
  • You want enhanced options exposure with slightly lower variance

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Articles

strategy
NAV Erosion vs Return of Capital: What High-Yield Investors Get Wrong
Learn the critical difference between true NAV erosion and return of capital distributions.
strategy
Understanding Liquidity Risk: Why AUM Matters More Than Yield
A practical guide to evaluating liquidity risk in dividend ETFs. Learn how low AUM, thin bid-ask spreads, and fund closures silently erode returns.
strategy
The Crash Test: How the Cornerstone Portfolio Survived 2022
A data-driven backtest of the Cornerstone Strategy vs. the S&P 500 during the inflation bear market.
View all articles →

See How IWMY or JEPY Fits Your Portfolio

Every investor has a unique risk profile. Use our Portfolio Intelligence tool to see the impact of adding these ETFs to your holdings.

Explore Related Comparisons

Compare IWMY vs...

ABNDX
AMEFX
AMRFX
BIL

Compare JEPY vs...

ABNDX
AMEFX
AMRFX
BIL