The Definitive Tier 5 Reference

Every YieldMax ETF Analyzed — The Real Numbers, Not the Yield

Headline yields tell you what the ETF pays. Total return tells you what you actually made. This guide has both numbers for every active YieldMax, Defiance, and Roundhill ETF — and the position sizing rules that make a Tier 5 allocation rational.

Get the Full Table

What High-Yield Investors Need Beyond the Headline Yield

Yield Without NAV Data Is Half the Picture

A 62% yield on an ETF that lost 41% NAV is a 21% total return. You need both numbers for every holding to know what you actually have.

Not All Tier 5 ETFs Perform Equally — The Spread Is Wide

The difference between the best and worst Tier 5 ETF total return over 18 months exceeds 40 percentage points. ETF selection inside Tier 5 matters significantly.

The Rotation Strategy Separates Active Tier 5 Investors from Passive Ones

Holding the same Tier 5 ETF regardless of NAV cycle underperforms a rotation approach based on NAV recovery signals by a measurable margin.

What's Inside

Chapters marked Most Relevant are specifically applicable to your situation.

1
The Rise of Single-Stock Derivative ETFs

Why YieldMax, Defiance, and Roundhill exist and who they're built for.

2
How YieldMax Works

The options mechanics: selling covered calls on single stocks to generate weekly/monthly income.

3
NAV Erosion Reality

Why 40-60% yields mechanically require NAV erosion and what the math actually shows.

4
Every Active Tier 5 ETF AnalyzedMost Relevant

TSLY, NVDY, CONY, MSFO, AMZY, GOOGY — yield, NAV 12-month, total return.

5
Defiance & Roundhill ETFsMost Relevant

QQQY, IWMY, SPYT — the competitors and how their mechanics differ.

6
Position Sizing Rules

Why Tier 5 should never exceed 15-20% of income portfolio; the math behind that limit.

7
The Rotation StrategyMost Relevant

How to rotate between single-stock synthetics based on NAV recovery signals.

8
Combining with Tier 1-2 for Total Return

How to use Tier 5 income to fund Tier 1-2 accumulation.

26 ETFs, full yield + NAV + total return

TSLY: 62% yield, -41% NAV over 18 months = +21% total return. NVDY: 58% yield, -22% NAV = +36% total return. CONY: 71% yield, -53% NAV = +18% total return. The full table has 26 entries.

Is This Guide Right for You?

This guide is for you if...

  • You hold or are actively evaluating YieldMax, Defiance, or Roundhill ETFs
  • You want total return data — yield plus NAV change — for every active Tier 5 ETF
  • You want to understand the rotation strategy for managing Tier 5 exposure
  • You track your holdings' performance against their actual total return, not just distributions
  • You want the position sizing math that makes a Tier 5 allocation defensible

This guide is NOT for you if...

  • You have no interest in Tier 5 ETFs and stick to Tier 1-3
  • You're looking for a simple buy-and-hold recommendation without active management
  • You want a beginner introduction rather than a data-dense reference
  • You're early in accumulation with no near-term income needs

Get the Complete Data Table for Every Active Tier 5 ETF

$99

One-time purchase. Instant download. No subscription.

Get the Full Table
Secure checkout via Stripe

Secure checkout creates access to the purchased guide PDF for download.

Not Ready to Buy?

Get the free weekly DivAgent Letter. NAV reality checks, distribution autopsies, and a new ETF tier each week. From the desk of the editor.